Lol I played Starfire as well! SSSAAAHWIFIWDIIII
My first SFB purchase was the Designer's Edition back in 1982 or '83. I had the three expansions too, and then I bought the Commander's Edition. I dropped out before the Captain's Edition was released, but I came back to the SFU a few years ago by playing the Cadet Game, then I got into Fed Com.
I prefer Starmada as well. I am finally able to play bigger scenarios with more ships per side. I'm impressed with the way the system handles things that are very complex in FC/SFB, such as cloaking and Tholian Webs. "Simple but not simplistic" is a great way to describe the game.