Topic: Spreadsheet Question
> I've started playing with the spreadshet, 'cause, like, "who
> wouldn't?"
>
> One thing that I'm not clear on is how much SU I'm using in
> any given design. The SU for weapons is listed, but how do I
> know if I'm over?
That's what the pink box is for... it lists the number of SUs remaining. If it is in parentheses, that means it's negative (i.e., you've gone over the limit).
> Oh, another thing in general. Hulls are listed simply by
> number of hull boxes. That's fine and works well. Is there
> any general guideline for how to spec out various classes of
> ships? Like, Frigates being 1 hull, Destroyers being 2-3,
> Cruisers being 3-5, or whatever.
>
> The sample ships give some guildance, but has anyone just
> made a chart?
If I had to make a list of the most-often questioned design choices, it would look like this:
1) Why only three batteries?
2) Why didn't you list size ranges for different ship types?
The reasons behind #2 are myriad, but here are the most important:
1) Because I don't like it. I don't know how many arguments I've gotten into about whether a "frigate" should be larger or smaller than a "destroyer". And if I see one more list that gives "dreadnought" as a type of "super-battleship" I'm gonna scream...
Frankly, ship types should be based on function, and vary between navies, rather than be fixed by the game designer according to size. But that's just my opinion.
2) Because of scale. Since there's no set decision on how big "big" is, it's entirely possible that whereas I think a "cruiser" is around 10 hull, someone else might like to have super-duper-sized ships running around, meaning cruisers are down around 3-4 hull.
In addition, as has been mentioned before, it is possible to "scale down" Starmada so that it is a starfighter game. In that case a "cruiser" would be off the chart, so to speak.
But none of this is preventing you from coming up with your own list for internal consistency... besides, the combat rating is the most important number, not hull size...
Majestic Twelve Games
cricket@mj12games.com