In a nutshell, in an effort to investigate fighter balance, we each created 2 550 point fleets, one with and one without fighters, and randomly matched them up.
In the first battle, I used a 250 pt BC with stealth, one spinal mount a single very large A battery ( ignores shields, increased damage) and sevaral smaller guns.
The rest of the fleet consisted of a CA with fairly good defenses, a glass cannon DD with a nasty gun and no shields, and 4 Corvettes for anti figher duty.
My opponents fleet was 2 CL sized (hull6) carriers with 2x spinal mounts, stealth and 3 small figher flights each. (1 int, 2 bomber), and a small escort (hull4?)
Long range fire destroyed 3 of the escort corvettes and heavily damaged the Cruiser. My BC missed consistently, only hitting once - as the a battery was getting destroyed.
We called the game after 5 turns, with all 4 of my escorts and my cruiser space dust, the BC damaged adn surrounded by `12 fighters. Both Carriers were heavly damaged, and the escort was destroyed.
I should have taken sunbursts. But I knew that.